A 15-year-old immigrant was brought to the clinic by her mother because client complains of shortness of breath, chest pains, diaphoresis and easy fatiguability
Physical Assessment
Case Study Template
Name:
________________________________________
Week of Class (1-8):
4
Body System focus area:
Cardiovascular
Case Study:
A 15-year-old immigrant was brought to the clinic by her mother because client complains of shortness of breath, chest pains, diaphoresis and easy fatiguability. She claims she has had on and off bouts of tonsillitis since she was a child that resulted in tonsillectomy surgery when she was 12. Last week, she was unable to participate in the cheerleading tryouts because of knee pain and a rash that she noticed on her trunk for the past 2 weeks.
Questions (if data is unavailable, indicate “unavailable”):
What is the client’s chief complaint?
The client’s chief complaint is shortness of breath, chest pain, diaphoresis and easy fatiguability.
What questions would you ask the client?
HPI (History of Present Illness)
When did the shortness of breath and chest pain first start, and has it been getting worse?
Does the chest pain radiate to any other area like arm, jaw, back?
How long have you had the knee pain, and is it in one or both knees?
Can you describe the rash on your trunk?
Have you had a sore throat or fever in the past few weeks before these symptoms?
How severe is the fatigue on a scale of 1–10, and does it affect your daily activities?
ROS (Review of Systems)
Cardiovascular: Do you experience palpitations, irregular heartbeat, or swelling in your legs or feet?
Respiratory: Do you have difficulty breathing at rest or only with activity? Any cough or wheezing?
Musculoskeletal: Are other joints affected besides the knee? Any joint stiffness or swelling?
Integumentary: Is the rash itchy or painful? Has it changed in appearance or spread?
Neurological: Have you experienced any involuntary movements, confusion, or difficulty concentrating?
Constitutional: Have you had fever, chills, unintentional weight loss, or decreased appetite?
Medical/Surgical/Psych History
How many episodes of tonsillitis did you have before the surgery, and were they treated with antibiotics?
Have you ever been diagnosed with strep throat? Were you treated and did you complete the full antibiotic course?
Do you have any other known medical conditions?
Have you had any other surgeries or hospitalizations?
Are you currently taking any medications, supplements, or herbal remedies?
Any history of anxiety, depression, or psychiatric conditions?
Family History
Does anyone in your family have a history of rheumatic fever or rheumatic heart disease?
Is there a family history of autoimmune diseases such as lupus or rheumatoid arthritis?
Any family history of congenital or structural heart defects?
Other
What country did you immigrate from, and when did you arrive?
What is your living situation?
Do you have any known allergies, especially to penicillin or other antibiotics?
What physical examinations would you include?
Body System
Include?
✓
(yes) or – (not indicated)
Notes
General survey
✓
Assess overall appearance, vitality, signs of distress, fever, weight
HEENT (head, eyes, ears, nose, throat/thyroid)
✓
Inspect throat for erythema/exudate; assess for lymphadenopathy
Cardiovascular
✓
Auscultate heart sounds (stethoscope to actual skin); assess for murmur, rub, gallop
Peripheral Vascular
✓
Assess pulses, capillary refill, edema in lower extremities
Breasts
–
Not indicated for this presentation
Lymphatic
✓
Palpate cervical, axillary lymph nodes for enlargement
Pulmonary
✓
Auscultate lung sounds — anterior and posterior; assess for crackles/rales
Gastrointestinal/Abdominal
✓
Assess for hepatosplenomegaly which may indicate cardiac involvement
Genitourinary/Pregnancy
–
Not indicated unless urinary symptoms present
Integumentary
✓
Assess trunk rash; document morphology, distribution (erythema marginatum)
Musculoskeletal
✓
Inspect and palpate knee; assess ROM, warmth, swelling; check for subcutaneous nodules
Neurological
✓
Assess for involuntary movements, coordination
What are the
pertinent positive
physical assessment findings?
Shortness of breath and chest pain consistent with carditis
Easy fatiguability suggesting decreased cardiac output
Knee joint pain (migratory polyarthritis, a major Jones criterion)
Trunk rash consistent with erythema marginatum (major Jones criterion)
History of recurrent Group A Streptococcal (GAS) tonsillitis, predisposing to autoimmune response
Diaphoresis indicating systemic inflammatory process
What are the
pertinent negative
physical assessment findings?
No documented fever at time of visit (unavailable)
No current sore throat or pharyngitis symptoms reported
No reported involuntary movements (chorea not documented)
No reported subcutaneous nodules on examination
No history of prior cardiac diagnosis or known heart murmur
What are at least 3 differential diagnoses?
Acute Rheumatic Fever (ARF) with carditis — most likely given the constellation of migratory arthritis, carditis symptoms, skin rash, prior streptococcal infection history, and immigrant status from a moderate- to high-risk region (Sejeeni et al., 2023)
Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis (JIA) — presents with joint inflammation in adolescents, may include systemic features; distinguished by absence of strep history and different rash morphology
Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE) — autoimmune condition that can present with arthritis, rash, and cardiopulmonary symptoms in adolescent females; ANA and dsDNA labs would differentiate
What is your primary diagnosis?
Acute Rheumatic Fever (ARF) with carditis. The client satisfies multiple revised Jones major criteria: clinical carditis (chest pain, dyspnea), migratory arthritis (knee pain), and erythema marginatum (trunk rash), with a significant history of recurrent GAS tonsillopharyngitis. ARF is an autoimmune disorder triggered by GAS pharyngeal infection, disproportionately affecting immigrants and socioeconomically disadvantaged youth (Zhuang et a., 2025).
What is your treatment plan?
Diagnostic Procedures
Echocardiogram (Doppler) to assess for valvular regurgitation and subclinical carditis (Ambari et al., 2024)
ECG to evaluate for PR prolongation (minor Jones criterion)
Throat swab culture for GAS
Labs
Anti-streptolysin O (ASO) titer and anti-DNase B antibodies
ESR and CRP (inflammatory markers)
CBC with differential, BMP, ANA panel to rule out alternative diagnoses
Client Education
Educate patient and mother on the importance of completing all antibiotic courses for any future strep infections
Explain the significance of secondary prophylaxis adherence to prevent ARF recurrence and rheumatic heart disease progression (Ambari et al., 2024)
Advise activity restriction until carditis is ruled out or resolved; avoid strenuous activity (cheerleading)
Pharmacotherapy
Penicillin V orally (or Benzathine penicillin G IM) to eradicate residual GAS (Ambari et al., 2024)
Aspirin or NSAIDs for arthritis and fever management
Corticosteroids (prednisone) if severe carditis is confirmed
Initiate secondary prophylaxis: Benzathine penicillin G IM every 3–4 weeks for minimum 10 years or until age 21
Health Promotion
Ensure up-to-date immunizations per CDC schedule
Screen household contacts for GAS and treat as appropriate
Address social determinants: crowded living, access to care, and health literacy for immigrant family
Follow-Up
Follow up in 2 weeks to review labs and echocardiogram results
Cardiology referral for confirmed carditis or valvular changes
Monthly penicillin prophylaxis monitoring and adherence counseling
References
Ambari, A. M., Radi, B., Dwiputra, B., Arityanti, D., Rikl, T., Inggriani, M. P., Qhabibi, F. R., Susilowati, E., Makes, I. K., Rudiktyo, E., Cramer, M. J., Doevendans, P., Setianto, B., & Santoso, A. (2024). Adherence to penicillin treatment is essential for effective secondary prevention of rheumatic heart disease: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
Annals of Medicine & Surgery
,
86
(4), 2116-2123.
https://doi.org/10.1097/ms9.0000000000001833
Sejeeni, N. F., Alfahmi, S. S., Alzhrani, R. M., Almatrafi, M. K., & Hussain, A. (2023). A case report: Acute rheumatic fever or something more?
Cureus
.
https://doi.org/10.7759/cureus.36967
Zhuang, S., Guo, D., & Yu, D. (2025). A mini review of the pathogenesis of acute rheumatic fever and rheumatic heart disease.
Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology
,
15
.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fcimb.2025.1447149
WEEK 4 CASE STUDY + RUBRIC
CARDIOVASCULAR Case : A 15-year-old immigrant was brought to the clinic by her mother because client complains of shortness of breath, chest pains, diaphoresis and easy fatiguability. She claims she has had on and off bouts of tonsillitis since she was a child that resulted in tonsillectomy surgery when she was 12. Last week, she was unable to participate in the cheer leading tryouts because of knee pain and a rash that she noticed on her trunk for the past 2 weeks.
Case Study Rubric
Case Study Rubric
Criteria
Ratings
Pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeAnswers items completely. Develops adequate responses to questions. The plan shows depth and application of course concepts.
10 to >7.5 ptsExemplary
The case study meets or exceeds expectations with creative, innovative strategies for the case study.
7.5 to >5.0 ptsProficient
The case study meets expectations by including good depth for all elements of plan but does not demonstrate good application of course content.
5 to >2.5 ptsSatisfactory
The case study meets minimal expectations with minimal development of portions of case study.
2.5 to >0 ptsEmerging
The case study does not meet expectations; the plan has no depth or has included inaccurate elements. No points awarded if not completed.
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIdentifies and describes pathophysiologic concepts and care as needed
10 to >7.5 ptsExemplary
The study meets or exceeds expectations with well-developed resources (e.g., textbook, peer-reviewed articles).
7.5 to >5.0 ptsProficient
The case study meets expectations; resources included are well developed in all but a few areas.
5 to >2.5 ptsSatisfactory
The study meets the minimal expectations with few resources included.
2.5 to >0 ptsEmerging
The case study does not meet expectations; no resources are included. No points awarded if not completed.
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeMechanics
Writing has good flow throughout, responses have good transitions, and no spelling or grammar errors. APA Style is used,
5 to >4.0 ptsExemplary
Written in a clear, concise, formal, and organized manner. Responses are mostly error free. Information from sources is paraphrased appropriately and accurately referenced and cited in current APA style when applicable.
4 to >3.0 ptsProficient
Writing is generally clear and organized but is not concise or formal in language. Multiple errors exist in spelling and grammar with minor interference with readability or comprehension. Most information from sources is paraphrased, referenced, and cited correctly in current APA style.
3 to >2.0 ptsSatisfactory
Writing is generally unclear and unorganized. Several errors in spelling and grammar. Information from sources is missing or improperly cited.
2 to >0 ptsEmerging
Errors in spelling and grammar detract from readability and comprehension, AND/OR writing includes slang or is inappropriate for academic discourse.
5 pts
Total Points: 25 A 15-year-old immigrant was brought to the clinic by her mother because client complains of shortness of breath, chest pains, diaphoresis and easy fatiguability